Skip to main content

Review Christmas Carol Goes Wrong at Manchester Opera House

Review Christmas Carol Goes Wrong Main
Published Date: 19 Nov 2026
Updated: 19 Nov 2026
Author: Gemma

There are plenty of ways to get into the Christmas spirit, but if you’re looking for something a little different from the traditional festive shows, Christmas Carol Goes Wrong at Manchester Opera House could be just the ticket.

I went along with my 14-year-old daughter, and it was my first experience of a Mischief Theatre production. I’ve heard plenty about The Play That Goes Wrong and their other shows, but I’ve never actually seen any of them. I was looking forward to finding out what all the fuss was about, and I certainly wasn’t disappointed!

A little about Mischief Theatre

Mischief Theatre was founded by a group of friends who met at university, including Henry Lewis, Jonathan Sayer and Henry Shields, who also wrote this production. They’ve built a huge following with their comedy shows, particularly The Play That Goes Wrong and Peter Pan Goes Wrong, as well as Magic Goes Wrong and The Comedy About A Bank Robbery.

Their productions take the things that can go wrong in theatre and turn them into comedy, with plenty of physical humour, perfectly timed mishaps and increasingly ridiculous situations. What looks like complete chaos on stage actually takes an incredible amount of skill and precision to pull off.

What is Christmas Carol Goes Wrong about?

Review Christmas Carol Goes Wrong at Manchester Opera House_Chris_Leask_Greg_Tannahill_and_Daniel_Fraser

If you know the story of Charles Dickens’ A Christmas Carol, you’ll have an idea of where this is supposed to be heading. The trouble is, this isn’t your usual production.

We’re introduced to the Cornley Amateur Dramatic Society, who have decided to tackle the much-loved Christmas classic. Unfortunately, things don’t quite go to plan. Between backstage disagreements, missing actors, a battle over who gets to play the leading role and a production that seems determined to fall apart, the company have their work cut out trying to get the show to the end.

It’s a play within a play, so we’re treated to both the behind-the-scenes antics of the amateur drama group and their rather unusual attempt at bringing Dickens’ story to life. I won’t give away any of the surprises, but let’s just say the Cornley cast end up with very  different version from how A Christmas Carol should be performed!

The cast and performances

Review Christmas Carol Goes Wrong at Manchester Opera House Sasha_Frost_and_Nancy_Zamit

I was really impressed with all of the cast.  Each actor brought their own personality and little quirks, and it’s lovely watching the different characters bounce off one another as the chaos unfolds.

Henry Shields plays Chris, the director of the production, who also takes on the role of Scrooge. Chris has very definite ideas about how everything should be done and isn’t particularly good at hiding his frustration when his fellow cast members fail to meet his expectations.

Shields is brilliant at switching between the increasingly exasperated director and the much more composed version of himself he tries to present to the audience.

Jonathan Sayer plays Dennis a wonderfully hapless, struggling to keep up with what’s happening around him and having a particularly difficult time remembering his lines and even more so making friends.

Sayer’s comic timing is brilliant, and there’s something about Dennis that makes you want to cheer him on, even when things are going spectacularly wrong. He was my favourite character of the evening, I found myself laughing every time he appeared. 

Robert (Henry Lewis) in contrast to Dennis is an actor with a rather large opinion of his own abilities and ambitions that don’t always go to plan. He offered some brilliant comic moments and even when a mishap meant he could not be seen he had everyone in stitches.

Review Christmas Carol Goes Wrong at Manchester Opera House Christmas Yet To Come_and_Daniel_Fraser

In fact there wasn’t a character that I didn’t like. 

From Jonathan (Greg Tannahill) who is dubbed the only one with an acting ability but after a terrifying incident as Peter Pan is now scared of heights. To Trevor (Chris Leask) the theatre technician that seems to find himself more onstage than at the back. And Max (Matt Cavendish) who charmed the audience with his inability to not smile even in the more sobre moment. 

Allie Dart plays Annie, the hardworking stage manager who is doing her best to keep the whole production together. She brings plenty of energy and enthusiasm to the role, and you can’t help feeling for her as she tries to keep everyone and everything under control all in the most enthusiastic way.

I would be amiss not to also Sandra (Sasha Frost) whose dream is to one day get an agent and make it to the big screen and plays the stoic narrator during for the teams production. How Frost managed to stay so composed as the chaos ensues around her I will never know And I do hope this little mentions helps Sandra get her to Russell Crowe one day. 

A special mention has to go for Tiny Tim, who was my daughter’s favourite. I’ll won’t say anything further but he certainly a character you will want to watch out for. 

The comedy 

The comedy is what makes this show such a treat. There is a mixture of slapstick, physical comedy, clever dialogue and wonderfully timed mishaps. Sometimes you can see something is about to go wrong, and you find yourself waiting for it to happen. The anticipation is almost as funny as the actual moment, and there are plenty of little details that you might not notice until they come into play.

What I hadn’t appreciated before seeing Mischief Theatre was just how much skill goes into making everything look so chaotic. The physical comedy is brilliant, and although it might look as though the cast are simply making things up as they go along, every movement and reaction has clearly been carefully rehearsed. It’s a very clever production, and I found myself laughing just as much at the little details as the bigger comedy moments.

Who is Christmas Carol Goes Wrong suitable for?

The show is aimed at audiences aged 8 and over, and I think that’s a sensible guide. There is some swearing there is a moment that my 14-year-old daughter said there was one particular part that she would probably have found quite frightening when she was younger.

That said, there is so much humour throughout that children will love. It’s a very physical comedy, with plenty of silly moments, visual gags and slapstick that don’t rely on understanding every joke. 

It’s a great choice for a family theatre trip, particularly if you enjoy comedy and don’t mind a little festive madness!

Would we recommend Christmas Carol Goes Wrong?

Absolutely! This is a brilliant show to get you in the mood for Christmas. We didn’t stop laughing throughout, and we certainly weren’t the only ones. The laughter started almost immediately and continued throughout.

As I mentioned earlier, the cheers that greeted the original company members as they appeared on stage made it clear that Mischief has a very firm fan base. I’m happy to say that, after this performance, I’m now one of them!

You don’t need to have seen any of their previous productions to enjoy this one. It’s funny, clever, wonderfully chaotic and full of festive fun.

If you’re looking for something a little different to the usual Christmas theatre trip, Christmas Carol Goes Wrong is a great choice.

Christmas Carol Goes Wrong is running at Opera House Manchester until the 21st November 2026 .

To book > Christmas Carol Goes Wrong 


You May Also Like…

Newsletter Signup